In the book, The Most
Controversial Decision by Wilson D. Miscamble, the bombing of Hiroshima and
Nagasaki during World War I was described and researched. As previously
described in my blog the first half of the book was strictly fact based to
provide a specific record of events leading up to the bombing. In the second
section, the actual event was described along with the aftermath including the
importance of the Japanese surrender as well as the brutal effects of the
radioactive bombs. The sections in which
these aspects of the event are described maintain an unbiased point of view and
provide numerous sources in the footnote of each page. This allowed readers to collect
straightforward, factual information and create their own opinion regarding the
bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Chapter seven entitled “Necessary, But Was
It Right?” while this seems like it would be an opinionated section, it was
not; rather it defended the bombing as well as critiqued it. Just as Miscamble
had in the recaps of history, he maintained the large amount of reliable
sources in the footnotes to show the credentials of him and his writing. After that section which vastly focused on
immediate results of the bombing, he went on to describe long-term effects of
the event such as the Cold War. The purpose of this book, to educate
intellectual adults on the controversial bombings in Japan to allow them to
form their own opinions on the matter, was achieved through Miscamble’s
strictly fact-based writing. By writing without incorporating his personal
views on the event he allows this book to be very reliable and provided a
well-rounded perspective of the bombing. This book is an effective recap of the
events before, during, and after the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombing which
allows readers to make educated decisions regarding whether or not they agree
with this event.
![]() |
Cover Page URL:http://www.tower.com/most-controversial-decision-truman-atomic-bombs-defeat-japan-wilson-d-miscamble-c-paperback/wapi/117398971 |